+- Xonotic Forums (https://forums.xonotic.org)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Off Topic (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=15)
+--- Thread: WebP Screenshots (/showthread.php?tid=1059)
WebP Screenshots - Dave - 10-01-2010
Hi. I downloaded the Google's WebP encoder to try out on some screenshots.
Original jpg, 272 KB
Converted to WebP, 210 KB
This concept is great in theory, but libvpx does not compress red well (yet?).
RE: WebP Screenshots - pyr0 - 10-01-2010
Especially the graph on the bottom right side looks less colorful.
RE: WebP Screenshots - clanclanclan - 10-01-2010
You really have to wonder if it's worth it for a ~23% saving in file size :S
It could cut bandwidth usage, but I don't like the loss of saturation
RE: WebP Screenshots - RoKenn - 10-01-2010
Those lossy formats have a "quality" parameter, at least jpeg has. So the question is how does the quality compare if you adjust them to create the same file size?
Or how does the file size compare, if you adjust it to have the same quality? ^^
RE: WebP Screenshots - Dave - 10-01-2010
(10-01-2010, 07:07 PM)RoKenn Wrote: Those lossy formats have a "quality" parameter, at least jpeg has. So the question is how does the quality compare if you adjust them to create the same file size?
Or how does the file size compare, if you adjust it to have the same quality? ^^
The above WebP file was at -quality 98. The jpeg encoder used in Nexuiz is also set to very high quality.
At -quality 100, the file size reaches 246 KB and the quality increase is nearly imperceptible.
If the issue with red encoding is fixed in libvpx, the gains in compression ability over jpeg would be significant.
Then the next issue becomes decoding speed.
RE: WebP Screenshots - PGP_Qz - 10-02-2010
Interesting format only for photos to be displayed on the Internet. In all other cases, PNG is better
RE: WebP Screenshots - edh - 10-02-2010
(10-01-2010, 02:58 PM)Dave Wrote: This concept is great in theory, but libvpx does not compress red well (yet?).A compression algorithm that happens to dislike a colour?
WebP does look interesting though. About time there is a replacement for JPEG that is open source and I only hope that other parties start supporting it.