+- Xonotic Forums (https://forums.xonotic.org)
+-- Forum: Creating & Contributing (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Forum: Xonotic - Suggestion Box (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+--- Thread: [SUGGESTION] CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) (/showthread.php?tid=87)
CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Erusavion - 03-24-2010
Maybe some type of advantage that an a player gains as the FC? Like maybe the health and armor decreases slower. I don't mean while being fired upon. I mean if you haven't collected health it doesn't decrease to 100 as fast as a non-FC would.
I've always thought that as an FC you should have some sort of advantage since you're already at a disadvantage from being hunted by almost every player on the other team.
Although, this could be bad because it would change the ideas of placement of health on maps since the FC can stack easier. Also, a good player would be able to stack to 999 pretty easily on most maps. I just thought I'd shoot an idea out.
This idea isn't really about easier health stacking. It's really about giving the FC some sort of advantage.
Or maybe this could be a separate game type. CTF Juggernaut maybe?
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - esteel - 03-24-2010
The general question will be: is this needed? I mean right now its already quite possible to capture flags or CTF would not be that popular. Also the flag carrier is/should-not-be alone when trying to get a flag. He has the rest of the team helping, either directly (a pair of attackers) or indirectly (defenders protecting the own flag and in general people fragging the other team)
If one were to give the flag carrier such an advantage there also would have to be a counter for that or the flag carriers could end up being unstoppable. Actually some of those fast freaking laserjumpers are already close to that once they got the flag... I know that sometimes its hard to get the flag but not impossible, basicly it means the other team has the better strategy.
So IMO if we want such a discussion it needs to be about dis/advantages. One popular way for this are runes (damage, speed, protection, ammo) in other games. Like you can choose to pickup a speed rune which makes you 1.5 as fast but limit health and armor. Or you get 2x the damage but get a bit slower.
Voted no because FC only advantages are bad!
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Liquid Sin - 03-24-2010
This idea didn't jump out at me at first (those fast freaking laser movers came to mind) But the rune idea making the decision to give up something for that extra boost in damage, speed, protection, noclip? lol not noclip but maybe something else I can't think of right now perhaps a double agent model rune pick it up and boom your the same colour guy as your enemy but you would have to sacrifice something major for that imo and it would have to be for a fairly limited amount of time idk it sounds fun though the thought of watching for sneaky looking team mates near the flag when the double agent rune is gone, Just a thought.
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Sepelio - 03-24-2010
I agree with esteel here. Most of the time on public servers I can grab a flag and be gone and capped in <15secs depending on the map and players. Flag carriers do not need an advantage.
I will say I do think Rune ctf would be nice to have.
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Silverburn - 03-24-2010
(03-24-2010, 04:50 AM)Sepelio Wrote: I agree with esteel here. Most of the time on public servers I can grab a flag and be gone and capped in <15secs depending on the map and players.Unless I frag you
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Vael - 03-24-2010
Good FCs are already plenty good.
I like the Rune CTF idea though.The only change that needs to be made for FCs is the scoring system for losing so many points when you die with the flag. Although, there should be an option to return to the harsher scoring system for tournament matches.
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Erusavion - 03-24-2010
Well, that's why I opened the discussion. I mentioned that good players would probably become invincible with some type of advantage. I really just want some mutated type of CTF. I'm getting bored of just running back and forth.
I do like the Rune CTF idea. Maybe we could expand on that?
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Liquid Sin - 03-24-2010
Yes rune CTF is sounding like something I want to play more I think about it.
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - esteel - 03-25-2010
People are working a modular mutator system at the moment.. guess when its finished it will be easier implementing such stuff
RE: CTF Gameplay (mostly FC) - Erusavion - 03-25-2010
Oh really? Well fantastic =D
Does anyone know if Clan Arena will be included as a game type rather than a mutation?