10-06-2012, 08:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2012, 02:41 PM by GreEn`mArine.)
Very good music and editing 
. Most frags are decent, some really awesome! Although I think it's a bit long, my head is dizzy after watching it 
Update: I watched it a second time. I know you're not going to do any changes, but I have these four minor things to rant about
(don't feel offended please)
1) The beep sound made by the rocket launcher once you start guiding the rocket is horribly loud and hurts my ears. Due to this sound I have to reduce the overall volume which is too bad, because I personally like the music and the general editing
2) Similar problem with the announcer sounds: they are too loud compared to the rest. They somehow feel to me as if they stick out of everything else.
3) The amount of particles spawned is too much. I often have the problem that I don't even "see" the frags, because they are covered by so many VFXs, like smoke or funny particles. Best examples are the teleporters and blood from killed opponents, they produce way too much. It's already hard to spot what's going on in general, due to the high detailed textures.
4) at around 7:30 the frag with the electro plasma balls reflected by the jumppad: if someone does not know that map he has no idea what's going on, or why the frag is so "unbelievable" as Antibody is commenting. You really should include a second camera perspective that shows what actually happened.
Also sometimes it feels as if some parts of the action were artificially accelerated (1.5x speed for example). Maybe that's just me not having played the game in such a long time, or not really knowing Xonotic to begin with (just Nexuiz).
. Most frags are decent, some really awesome! Although I think it's a bit long, my head is dizzy after watching it Update: I watched it a second time. I know you're not going to do any changes, but I have these four minor things to rant about
(don't feel offended please)1) The beep sound made by the rocket launcher once you start guiding the rocket is horribly loud and hurts my ears. Due to this sound I have to reduce the overall volume which is too bad, because I personally like the music and the general editing
2) Similar problem with the announcer sounds: they are too loud compared to the rest. They somehow feel to me as if they stick out of everything else.
3) The amount of particles spawned is too much. I often have the problem that I don't even "see" the frags, because they are covered by so many VFXs, like smoke or funny particles. Best examples are the teleporters and blood from killed opponents, they produce way too much. It's already hard to spot what's going on in general, due to the high detailed textures.
4) at around 7:30 the frag with the electro plasma balls reflected by the jumppad: if someone does not know that map he has no idea what's going on, or why the frag is so "unbelievable" as Antibody is commenting. You really should include a second camera perspective that shows what actually happened.
Also sometimes it feels as if some parts of the action were artificially accelerated (1.5x speed for example). Maybe that's just me not having played the game in such a long time, or not really knowing Xonotic to begin with (just Nexuiz).
