+- Xonotic Forums (https://forums.xonotic.org)
+-- Forum: Creating & Contributing (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Forum: Xonotic - Suggestion Box (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+--- Thread: [SUGGESTION] Idea for Hagar (/showthread.php?tid=1220)
Idea for Hagar - Mirio - 11-16-2010
The Hagar is and always was a kinda useless weapon, so I thought about a way to fix this. I said my idea already in IRC some days ago and some people liked it so I will share it here.
I thought about a "disarm" function (something similar to the Shotgun secondary) that you can slap an enemy and you get his weapon that hes using at the moment. I don't know if this should make damage, if so only a little.
Cheers
RE: Idea for Hagar - jaykay - 11-16-2010
i don't knwo how good the idea is but it is not related to the hagar so it wouldnt make sense to replace the hagar with that disarm-weapon. maybe it's better for laser secondary.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Cuinnton - 11-16-2010
I always wanted to see both of these 2 functions with the hanger.
1) Either giving them a slight homing ability, making a it a very powerful spamming weapon. Maybe you must have to lock onto you target as making it slightly harder to get this function
2) Rockets become 'smart'. Instead of being a 'mini rapid fire bazooka' Rockets are shot and maintain a distance of 3m from the user, creating a thin rocket shield. When fire button is released a swam are mini rockets a shot forward.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Minkovsky - 11-17-2010
That would make it too powerful. Kinda.
I'd say that the first one is cool.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Lee_Stricklin - 11-17-2010
Never thought the hagar was unbalanced, well maybe the balanceFruit one, though the spread on it was intended to make it more useful against airborne players. I find that the hagar is best used when you lead the opponent and blast the floor near them or pin them against a wall. You can also use the secondary to cause panic around a corner or clear a room out.
RE: Idea for Hagar - rainerzufalldererste - 11-17-2010
i agree, that it should be more powerful... some ideas:
1) Charging and in the right moment having a "shotgun"-like Hagar! [secondary]
2) Special ammunition! ...or the ability to "buy" it for rockets (20 rockets -> fire ammunition)
3) have a no-damage-secondary which can be used like a jet-pack (aiming down)
4) make it a high-speed-RL! (less damage)
5) secondary like RL but bouncing and not that fast!
RE: Idea for Hagar - The mysterious Mr. 4m - 11-17-2010
i have more frags with Hagar seondary than with primary, mostly because opposing players don't dodge what comes from behind them. (Which they should. Apparently.)
With such a disarm feature, my bind "Give me that!" would make more sense and i could use it more often.
RE: Idea for Hagar - SinSniper - 11-17-2010
hagar isn't stupid, only underestimated, his secondary fire is a great spamming option, plus can be used for little jumps in duels and avoids to get too much high and be an easy target
RE: Idea for Hagar - Rad Ished - 11-18-2010
Hagar is way underrated. You have to creatively lead the target to get the most out of it.
RE: Idea for Hagar - unfa - 11-24-2010
I also thaught about making the primary Hagar fire a bit homing to players. The secondary seems a bit more usefull than the primary. As it gives you much more chance of direct hit. I think that Hagar is a powerfull gun. but it can't be used from too much distance (too slow projectiles) and requires a lot of skill with it, which I don't have
We don't have any homing missles in the game already, so making Hagar's primary homing a bit would be a cool twist to the game.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-24-2010
It seems to me that the Hagar is one of those 'un-discovered' weapons. Those who haven't caught onto it don't use it to its full advantage, and think it useless. Those who have, like it.
Me, I like it a lot. One of my favorite weapons actually. Though that may be because I haven't faced any real challenges that might exploit weaknesses I don't see in it.
A slight homing feature on it would be cool, though.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Mirio - 11-25-2010
(11-24-2010, 07:32 AM)unfa Wrote: I also thaught about making the primary Hagar fire a bit homing to players.
This would be the TAG Seeker, no?
RE: Idea for Hagar - Calinou - 11-25-2010
(11-25-2010, 08:00 AM)Mirio Wrote:No. A bit != a lot. Tag seeker is useless... if it's removed, then, make the hagar a bit homing.(11-24-2010, 07:32 AM)unfa Wrote: I also thaught about making the primary Hagar fire a bit homing to players.
This would be the TAG Seeker, no?
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-25-2010
After testing it out in an arena match, I fell in love with the Tag Seeker. Pure awesomeness. High speed strategy with lots of effects.
RE: Idea for Hagar - unfa - 11-25-2010
Yeah, I like TAG seeker too. And: no, Hagar would be totally different gun from TAG if it was homing A BIT.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Mirio - 11-25-2010
How can something homing only "a bit" ?
TAG Seeker > Hagar !
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-25-2010
They wouldn't lock on and track: they would slide more in the direction of the enemy instead of scattering so much. Make sense?
RE: Idea for Hagar - tZork - 11-26-2010
I dont think semi auto-aim/track is a good idea for this type of game, specially not for a weapon with high rate of fire. the tag solves it by requiring the user to hit a difficult shot first, rocket launcher by inhibiting refire/weaponswitch for as long as you guide it. Without something like this a guided weapon would wreck hell on balance methinks.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-26-2010
I see what you mean. I think you are right.
I am having a hard time explaining my idea though... it really isn't like tracking or guided missiles at all. I might be wrong about that though.
Look at it this way:
If you fire the Hagar, assume you get a four foot spread (for example's sake). If there is an enemy in the left side of those four square feet, the rockets in the right side swerve slightly towards him. That way the spread is only about one by two square feet.
The spread merely narrows to the target, it doesn't follow the target, if that makes any sense.
RE: Idea for Hagar - kojn^ - 11-26-2010
Hagar isn't as bad as I thought actually, it's really pretty a very balanced (strong) weapon then compared to nexuiz in it's use.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-26-2010
Methinks I will do some deathmatch tests with Hagar as it currently is to see what I think after extended use.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Flying Steel - 11-26-2010
(11-26-2010, 10:28 AM)tZork Wrote: I dont think semi auto-aim/track is a good idea for this type of game, specially not for a weapon with high rate of fire. the tag solves it by requiring the user to hit a difficult shot first, rocket launcher by inhibiting refire/weaponswitch for as long as you guide it.
It wouldn't be imbalanced if the missiles only tracked targets within 10 meters or so. Then you have to lead them near to your enemy before they start course correcting.
It's a mechanic that's worked in numerous other games. Also with such a feature, the Hagar wouldn't necessarily need such a high fire rate, so you could turn in down.
RE: Idea for Hagar - Sir Emeth Mimetes - 11-27-2010
A possible suggestion for Hagar improvement:
Turn the secondary mode into a frag grenade. Meaning it explodes into shards that have a wide destruction radius. It would be risky to use, because you might hurt yourself if you aren't careful. Balanced.
It would detonate like the old version of the secondary mode on the Mortar (goes out and then explodes at a specified range).
Logistically, it would work similarly to what the secondary on Hagar has now: good for around corners, but dangerous to use in the same room as you.