+- Xonotic Forums (https://forums.xonotic.org)
+-- Forum: Creating & Contributing (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Forum: Xonotic - Suggestion Box (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+--- Thread: [SUGGESTION] Display nic names + account control ? (/showthread.php?tid=1343)
Display nic names + account control ? - lunitix - 12-15-2010
Hello people,
Wouldn't it be nice if there was a mechanism to disallow users from changing their names in game . For example as we have seen in nexuiz some retards change their names to match another player's name and annoy that player.(OR another example was that time we had a whole list of Bob's playing in one server...okay I admit that was somewhat funny but you know what I am talking about)
It could be great if the game prevented such possibilities by at least checking if that name is already used in the server.Ideally it would be great if there was a unique on-line server were players would need to register but since that is difficult and requires dedicated servers ,resources, customizations etc , I believe that it is more feasible and actually rather simple for each server hosting the game to have the ability to check whether a nick is used already locally.
What do you say ?
Cheers
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - Mirio - 12-15-2010
Heh. I want the people back who were around at "Bob" times! Bobs where a bunch of advanced players , myself included.
But yes, nickfaking is annoying.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - unfa - 12-15-2010
Personally I never found it a problem that my nick can be anything, and can be changed 5 times a second. I like this.
Personally I use it to add a little "description" or MOTD in my nick, so some folks of mine know what I'am up to right now.
I also know a compatriot of mine, who is frequently changing his nick, but I can always recognize it's him, because he always uses CAPITAL%YELLOW%LETTERS%WITH%RED%SPLATS%REPLACING%SPACES.
There is no other guy like him out there
Please don't take those possibilities from me. From him. From us, the players.
If someone is using abusive nicks or what, if you are really frustrated - kick him, or leave the server
I never met anyone who made me think "damn, this nick freedom has to be ended!". Really. Even if there are 12 Bobs playing on the server (CTF). And all you see is Bob took the blue flag, Bob fragged Bob, Bob was in a wrong place, etc.... I'd say that's awesome
I wish I saw something like this and could participate!
And if I saw someone with nick "I FℿℶK YOUR MOM LOL" it doesn't offend me. It makes me giggle. He either has to be an intelligent person with a strange sense of humor, or a troll. I don't feel offended.
I.e, I am AGAINST limiting nick fun. I'd be rather into giving players even more freedom. Freedom is fun, freedom is liberity. Liberity is GPL
Blah, blah All in all, this is just my own opinion, I'am not telling that it's the only good view on things, that's just my humble, humble...
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - divVerent - 12-15-2010
Personally, I think we should get a VOLUNTARY nick name registration system. It would allow registering your nickname to your unique player ID. If someone else tries to register the same nick, he is refused. However, other players would still be able to use the nick - but if your current nick is registered to your player ID, you would get an extra icon on the scoreboard stating that your nick is "verified". A nickfaker then simply cannot get that icon, and anyone concerned about "nickfakers" can register.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - lunitix - 12-15-2010
(12-15-2010, 09:39 AM)divVerent Wrote: Personally, I think we should get a VOLUNTARY nick name registration system. It would allow registering your nickname to your unique player ID. If someone else tries to register the same nick, he is refused. However, other players would still be able to use the nick - but if your current nick is registered to your player ID, you would get an extra icon on the scoreboard stating that your nick is "verified". A nickfaker then simply cannot get that icon, and anyone concerned about "nickfakers" can register.
That sounds like a good option.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - Mirio - 12-15-2010
This sounds very good divVerent! Want!
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - Sepelio - 12-15-2010
divVerent's idea seems like the way to go.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - rainerzufalldererste - 12-15-2010
(12-15-2010, 11:03 AM)Sepelio Wrote: divVerent's idea seems like the way to go.
+1
Code:
Uh... verify me xDRE: Display nic names + account control ? - nowego4 - 12-15-2010
Hmmm--better make sure you can only register your current nick, other wise we could run into nick hogs.
Otherwise, as soon as Xonotic gets an offical release I'm gonna register 'Player'.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - unfa - 12-16-2010
(12-15-2010, 03:16 PM)rainerzufalldererste Wrote:(12-15-2010, 11:03 AM)Sepelio Wrote: divVerent's idea seems like the way to go.
+1
Code:Uh... verify me xD
+1
(12-15-2010, 03:16 PM)nowego4 Wrote: Hmmm--better make sure you can only register your current nick, other wise we could run into nick hogs.
You mean: allow guys register only one nick? Sure! But let them change it anyways
There could be someting like username (that you register for) that can be like your name on this forum. Unchangable. But - in the game you could use different nick anyway. Login basically can be used to identify registered players. Despite that anybody could use any nick he wants, but anyone could also view detailed player's description and see what is login of each player. Admis could also kick/ban players by [logins / unique IDs] so that ban will last... ...f0r3\/@RRR!!!1oneone
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - lunitix - 12-16-2010
divVerent's idea is also a good option for the nick stealers not just nickfakers.
For example there was a very good player named Someone , but then someone else was logging is as someone , and then someone got frustrated at that someone and was forced to use another nick.So to recap Someone is no longer someone because someone else "stole" Someone's nick, can you tell someone apart from someone ?
The general idea is to protect your nick .
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - Mirio - 12-16-2010
(12-16-2010, 07:41 AM)unfa Wrote: Admis could also kick/ban players by [logins / unique IDs] so that ban will last... ...f0r3\/@RRR!!!1oneone
This would make a ban actually usefull.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - nowego4 - 12-16-2010
(12-16-2010, 07:41 AM)unfa Wrote:(12-15-2010, 03:16 PM)nowego4 Wrote: Hmmm--better make sure you can only register your current nick, other wise we could run into nick hogs.
You mean: allow guys register only one nick? Sure! But let them change it anyways
Precisely. Your current nick would be your registered nick (well, I guess you could have one nick registered and be playing as a different unregestered one if you wanted).
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - unfa - 12-17-2010
Yeeeah. My point is: you register for a nick, say I register for "unfa", right? But I think "unfa" is a pretty damn boring nick. So instead I type:
unfa | making dubstep is fun
And as long as my nick contains the "unfa" phrase, and I'am identified (registered) for "unfa" I get a little "registrered" icon in the chat'n'sconretab, and noboy else can get that symbol while using word "unfa" in their nick. So when 5 people use it, I'am the only one who has it registered, and I'am happy. And they are fake nick loosers.
If I decide to change my nick to "Lagissimo", then the "registered" icon disappears, because I don't use my registered nick (keyword) in my actual nick. But anybody can view my player details and see something like this:
. Lagissimo
. ---------
. ping: 5972 ms
. packet loss: ~99.9%
. ---------
. registered for: unfa
. unique ID: 295876476439824257987642598
. member since: 33th Moron 2011
. email: unfa@stickoffame.com
. ---------
. [invite as friend]
. [accept as friend]
. [ignore in chat]
. [avoid this freak]
If I haven't registered it would look like:
. Lagissimo
. ---------
. ping: 5972 ms
. packet loss: ~99.9%
. ---------
. unregistered
. IP: 666.1.2.3.4
. ---------
. [ignore in chat]
. [avoid this freak]
That shoudn't be too unfair.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - nowego4 - 12-17-2010
Only problem with that is that someone could register 'ing' (for example). Then anybody that wanted to have a word in their nick with 'ing' in it (for example, 'Bob Herring') couldn't register.
If you wanted to add a limit so that your registered nick had to be x letters long, (let's say 4 for now), this might help but wouldn't fix the problem (for example, someone could register '[BOT]' (five letters) and then no one in [BOT] clan could put that in their nick, they'd have to play around with spaces or caps or something).
If the limit were cranked up to 6, for example, then people with shorter names (like 'unfa') couldn't register.
A possible solution: Give each player 2 spots to register, so that they can register their normal name ('unfa') and another spot for when they want to shake things up with out risking someone else taking their first nick ('unfa likes snowboarding'). Would that work?
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - Mirio - 12-17-2010
Why not just like this:
- Registered nick = Forums nick
- You get an icon in game
- You can change your in game name to whatever you want
- With simple 'whois' function people can see "Aha he is registered as 'xyz' "
So if anyone is using for example 'unfa' as in game nick and you do a "whois", but hes registered as "nickfaker" you can tell its not the real unfa.
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - rainerzufalldererste - 12-17-2010
. [LAG]Lagissimo [online]
. server: balance testing server 123 [join]
. ---------
. ping: 5972 ms
. packet loss: ~99.9%
. ---------
. registered for: unfa
. unique ID: 295876476439824257987642598
. member since: 33th Moron 2011
. reputation: 6
. email: unfa@stickoffame.com
. ---------
. [invite as friend]
. [accept as friend]
. [ignore in chat]
. [avoid this freak]
some edits xD
RE: Display nic names + account control ? - nowego4 - 12-17-2010
(12-17-2010, 11:16 AM)Mirio Wrote: Why not just like this:
- Registered nick = Forums nick
- You get an icon in game
- You can change your in game name to whatever you want
- With simple 'whois' function people can see "Aha he is registered as 'xyz' "
So if anyone is using for example 'unfa' as in game nick and you do a "whois", but hes registered as "nickfaker" you can tell its not the real unfa.
Yes, this would be a viable alternative as well.