+- Xonotic Forums (https://forums.xonotic.org)
+-- Forum: Creating & Contributing (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Forum: Xonotic - Suggestion Box (https://forums.xonotic.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+--- Thread: [SUGGESTION] Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? (/showthread.php?tid=3077)
Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - Loafers - 05-31-2012
Thoughts?
Should switching to a weapon that's already equipped switch to the previous weapon? - rafallus - 05-31-2012
No.
Reason?
Incredibly counter-intuitive.
Current line of thinking:
"I want to switch to previous weapon" > [uses bind switching to previous weapon, whatever it was] > voila!
That line of thinking:
"I want to switch to previous weapon" > [checks what weapon equipped and looks for proper bind] > [ponders, how does it make sense, that pressing a button supposed to equip weapon A equips weapon B instead] > "Ok, let's switch" > switches.
BTW Forum error - can't quick reply, because adding RE: makes subject name too long.
RE: Darn lang subject - Halogene - 05-31-2012
Hey, that's how I reload my MG! I don't have a bind for previous weapon nor for reload, if this is going to happen I'll be DOOOOMED! D:
Should switching to a weapon that's already equipped switch to the previous weapon? - Loafers - 05-31-2012
(05-31-2012, 02:27 AM)rafallus Wrote: No.
Reason?
Incredibly counter-intuitive.
Current line of thinking:
"I want to switch to previous weapon" > [uses bind switching to previous weapon, whatever it was] > voila!
That line of thinking:
"I want to switch to previous weapon" > [checks what weapon equipped and looks for proper bind] > [ponders, how does it make sense, that pressing a button supposed to equip weapon A equips weapon B instead] > "Ok, let's switch" > switches.
BTW Forum error - can't quick reply, because adding RE: makes subject name too long.
I didn't think it would be that complicated...
(AND LOL @ SUBJECT TOO LONG)
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - Mr. Bougo - 05-31-2012
I reworded the subject, should work now. This forum behaviour sucks a bit.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - tZork - 05-31-2012
Regardless of what one thinks of it, it wont even work as some weapons share buttons. And as mentioned, it seems terribly counter-intuitive.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - divVerent - 05-31-2012
However, I wonder if we can do this as optional facility, like "switch to weapon X or to previous weapon".
So this won't work for the existing multi-binds, but single-weapon binds could be made that switch to previous if the weapon is already held.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - W4RP1G - 05-31-2012
I see no purpose for this. Switching back takes more thinking than switching to a specific weapon. Example, when switching back, you have to think about what weapon you currently have(so you know which key to press), what the last weapon you had was, then decide whether or not that's the weapon you want. When using proper weapon binds, you only have to think about which weapon you want.
I don't even know if you could do it on reflex either, there are just so many variables.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - freefang - 05-31-2012
Actually sounds lik something that could convince me to set up some weapon binds.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - Loafers - 05-31-2012
Thanks for all the replies.
For me this feature would make weapon switching a little easier. For example, I bind RL to q and pressing other binds can sometimes be awkward. Not to mention some people don't bind previously used weapon.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - W4RP1G - 05-31-2012
(05-31-2012, 04:00 PM)Loafers Wrote: Thanks for all the replies.
For me this feature would make weapon switching a little easier. For example, I bind RL to q and pressing other binds can sometimes be awkward. Not to mention some people don't bind previously used weapon.
How many buttons does your mouse have? A 5-way mouse wheel alone can go a long way towards helping with that problem, imo(although it depends on the quality of the mouse). Once the shotgun is removed, you'll have 1 less bind to worry about too.
RE: Should switching to the already equipped weapon switch to the previous weapon? - CuBe0wL - 06-01-2012
weapprev alias is already there in the game.
I can't give you the config right now (my knowledge gone a bit rusty), but with some alias magic you can do the following:
You simply bind a button to an alias, that on click (+alias) switches to desired weapon, on release (-alias) rebinds the button to "switchalias". "switchalias" rebinds that button to weapprev, and on click rerebinds to original weapon alias.
In quake2 I had a similar one, but for chat messages.